I'm so happy someone else made this joke. I was this close to making it myself.

10/10 would r8 again

I don't see how this could be "Rising From the Ashes." I feel like someone only made this as a joke, without a care for the prompt.

excuse me, Shadow Ashes is MY original character. whoever drew this is gonna be in big trouble for stealing him.

>>Haze
U w0t m8

nooo 'Es my OC

8/10 - IGN.com

(In all seriousness I'm glad to see straight up humor in the mix. I've no idea how to judge these but the laugh counts for something in my book.)

OMS! I LUV UR OC!!! Hes totally hot. Can I rite him intu my fic about my OC Sahdow? He wood be PURFECT with my editor's OC Enoby. She luvs dark and goffik characters with a deep backstry.

Unfortuntely I can't submit my crossover 2 da writeoffs becus DUMB rodger said we cant rite stories about our previus things. FUK U RODGER!!!

(I'm so sorry. I couldn't not comment on this one, not with an alias like this on my account.)

Too late, I've stolen it and involved him in a group orgy with the darkest fetishes you can find on the internet (I let your mind do the rest).

It was a good laugh so top of the low tier for me.

FLAMESFLAMESFLAMES

I hope this was literally actually made in pony creator.

>>xXx_quill_da_goffik_scratch_xXx EXCUZ ME ENOBY IZ MUH OC DONUT STEEL

Is this about bad pony OC's? Well I'm glad I'm an earth pony then. Granted a recolored 63 flipped trap of a pony but it expresses me. Makes me question if my ponysona is whack or not. Hm. Should make a blonde version of this pony and name it Floppy Twinkie.

>>xXx_quill_da_goffik_scratch_xXx
Yeah! Fuk Rodger! You show him!

While the text helps the joke, I have to admit that it is also what carries it - which raises the question of how much we want to reward art which is heavily reliant on text. The text isn't particularly well-integrated into the piece - it isn't something like "Ceci n'est pas une pipe", this is a label.

...This isn't even the worst OC I've ever seen.

While I appreciate the meta, I wish to give my favor and rankings to artists who put effort and deeper thought into their works, so this one goes in the lowest ranks.

>>TitaniumDragon
I summon the mighty power of French! Come to me Monokeras! Come to me Molière! Bless me with the power to finally correct an Englishman instead of being corrected by them everytime!
"Ceci n'est pas une pipe"!!!!!!!

...sorry.

>>GroaningGreyAgony
I actually don't have a problem giving this one a decent ranking. Sure It's a joke, but I think it lands.

>>CoffeeMinion
Comedy is an acceptable subject, isn't it?

It's all fun and games until somepony gets a cupcake in the eye.

>>Not_A_Hat
It was, note the accessories, like that watch.

@caption_rates
I had to change my system font to Comic Sans so this cappy would match its drawggo. Now I can't change it back. 12/10, please send help

Confession time: I made this thing. I am both proud and ashamed of it. Especially since several of you crazy people decided it would be a good idea to write a story about it. I look forward to reading those when I have some more time.

And if anyone is crazy enough to actually want to use this beautiful OC for anything (I'm looking at you, >>xXx_quill_da_goffik_scratch_xXx), here's the Pony Creator code: 2S2S00728126262611111103011E50707PL153A204010000X0C90808FF7FFF11107F3FCC004CB2

And thank you everyone!
>>Kritten
>>MLPmatthewl419
>>Haze
>>CoffeeMinion
>>xXx_quill_da_goffik_scratch_xXx
>>Fenton
>>Not_A_Hat
>>Posh
>>Remedyfortheheart
>>RodgerDodger is a PooFace
>>TitaniumDragon
>>The_Letter_J
>>GroaningGreyAgony
>>Fenton
>>CoffeeMinion
>>Moosetasm
>>horizon