Hey! It looks like you're new here. You might want to check out the introduction.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
Sunset and Starlight's dueling was pretty funny. And you could do a pretty good story about searching for more alicorns. But this just didn't cohere for me. Which is to say I don't really have a lot to add to the criticism that has already been given. Loved Starlight's switchblade, though, that got a good laugh out of me.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
The names of supporting characters usually aren't very important, but naming one "Feghoof" is a dangerous game. It took me out of the story for a moment to wonder what the punchline was going to be. That's no good, and it's sad to see the rest of the story overshadowed by a throwaway detail like that.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
I smell a crackfic. There's not really a lot to say about this one, I think. It knows what it is.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
It feels too short. Yes, it's a minific round, but it just runs into the word limit and stops instead of trying to give us a conclusion. It doesn't work as a minific, I think--I want to read the novel this feels like it's from.
>>Samey90
"Taking the fight to Mars" looks right to me. It's talking about going from fighting Martians on earth to fighting Martians on Mars.
>>Samey90
"Taking the fight to Mars" looks right to me. It's talking about going from fighting Martians on earth to fighting Martians on Mars.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6c9/0b6c9ecdd91efc4170412c47b03945b9e24a4c45" alt=""
What! it didn't make finals! how can this be?
All joking aside, at least now maybe my eye will stop twitching over that uncapitalized 'c' in the title.
>>Trick_Question
>>Bachiavellian
I can't dispute this criticism, I'm afraid. Looking back, I can't seem to remember that I was trying to do anything with this beyond present a very weird situation. It was one of those stories that started out as a clear mental image, and ended up just being a description of that, rather than trying to live on its own as a story.
One thing I want to mention, which I'll relate to the stories failure to really say anything, since I can't figure out how else to segue into it: I stole the idea for this (in broad strokes). The image this story is based off of is a rip off of a scene from Gravity's Rainbow ("It was a giant Adenoid!..." pg 14), a book which, while even more absurd than this, certainly has quite a lot to say.
>>horizon
Thank you for the advice, it is much appreciated. This particular story I think I might just take behind the shed instead of rewriting (my only hesitation in doing so is the first line, which I'm a little attached to), but I will think about this stuff the next time around.
Thank you all again, for the feedback and not calling my piece a trollfic. Have a wonderful writeoff.
All joking aside, at least now maybe my eye will stop twitching over that uncapitalized 'c' in the title.
>>Trick_Question
>>Bachiavellian
I can't dispute this criticism, I'm afraid. Looking back, I can't seem to remember that I was trying to do anything with this beyond present a very weird situation. It was one of those stories that started out as a clear mental image, and ended up just being a description of that, rather than trying to live on its own as a story.
One thing I want to mention, which I'll relate to the stories failure to really say anything, since I can't figure out how else to segue into it: I stole the idea for this (in broad strokes). The image this story is based off of is a rip off of a scene from Gravity's Rainbow ("It was a giant Adenoid!..." pg 14), a book which, while even more absurd than this, certainly has quite a lot to say.
>>horizon
Thank you for the advice, it is much appreciated. This particular story I think I might just take behind the shed instead of rewriting (my only hesitation in doing so is the first line, which I'm a little attached to), but I will think about this stuff the next time around.
Thank you all again, for the feedback and not calling my piece a trollfic. Have a wonderful writeoff.